Finicky Foods mission stems from the love of our home state of North Carolina and the joy of Southern snack foods. With meticulously crafted recipes and sustainable packaging, we are the first gourmet pimento cheese in reusable glass jars!

pimento cheese

pimento cheese

Small-batch pimento cheese like you’ve never tasted before!

In our recipes, we use brands you recognize like Duke’s Mayonnaise and Philadelphia Cream Cheese. Our spice mixes come from a place of curiosity. We like to play with fun flavors like Taco, Coastal, Port Wine, and more! Our spice sources come from Harmony House Foods, Savory Spice Shop Charlotte and other local shops with unique and memorable blends.

F L A G S H I P F L A V O R S
smoked gouda
fiery
sweet carolina
vegan original
vegan jalapeño

S E A S O N A L
everything
dill

Pre-order for pickup at Waxhaw Farmers Market.

What people are saying…

  • Catherine

    “It was no joke the best vegan cheese I've ever had. Vegan cheese is so hard to get right and girl.... that was just straight-up amazing.”

  • Curating the Carolinas

    “We have enjoyed lots of local pimento cheese but Finicky Foods was exceptional! The perfect texture and flavor.”

  • Hal

    “I talk about it like it’s a mythical creature I’ve seen once.”

  • Theresa

    “I just bought your last vegan pimento dip at Rhino Market. My kids give it two thumbs up!”

  • Local Carolinas

    “I was a little nervous to try the vegan pimento dip but I did and it was FANTASTIC, even my husband loves it.”

  • Chandler

    “Seriously so good. I had to stop eating it so I could take some home to my wife.”

  • DK

    “Crushing some of the smoked gouda right now on a Triscuit!”

  • Josh

    “Best pimento cheese in Charlotte.”

  • Megan

    “Your vegan jalapeno pimento dip is easily the best vegan “cheese” I’ve ever freakin had.”

  • Karla

    “I have been stopping by Rhino every day to grab more because it is by far one of the most amazing renditions of a great Southern sandwich spread.”

  • Justin

    “Love your pimento cheese.”

  • Kellie

    “Best pimento cheese I’ve ever had.”

  • Haley

    “We used your vegan pimento cheese to make veggie burgers and they were amazing. We absolutely loved it.”