Meet the Owner

Jessica began making pimento cheese as a party appetizer when hosting campout parties with her husband on their property in Waxhaw, NC. Friends and family would tell her again and again that she should start selling it to the public. A few years later, she officially launched Finicky Foods.

Sustainability

We are serious about environmentally friendly solutions. The goal of reusable glass and compostable packaging has been a top priority from the very beginning. We are now distributing reusable glass jars in retail locations and using compostable plant-based containers at pop-up markets.

Quality Counts

In the South, it’s Duke’s or else. We partner with local spice companies, use Philadelphia Cream Cheese, and dehydrated goods from Harmony House Foods in Western NC. We are committed to bringing that homemade flavor you know and love to Charlotte and beyond!

Media

  • Dieline

    Mindful & Good’s artful packaging design for Finicky Foods.

    Link

  • WBTV QC Life

    Making pimento cheese LIVE on QC@3 with Jorge!

  • Scoop Charlotte

    Featured in their article about ‘Women of CLT’. Photo by Slice of Jess.

    Link

  • Esther & Elsa

    Signage is a huge part of getting a customer to engage with your business. Instead of the usual banner with your logo, try this creative way of getting attention. Balloons are eye-catching, inexpensive, and a fun option to sell your product in a unique way. Photo by Rico Marcel Photography.

  • Bohemian Style House

    “You can’t go wrong with Finicky Foods pimento cheese. It’s life-changing.” - Megan

  • Slice of Jess

    ‘Meet Your Local’ edition making pimento cheese.

    Link

  • CLT Charcuterie

    Perfectly placed on their delicious and customizable charcuterie boards.

  • Protagonist Brewing

    A beer & pimento cheese pairing to celebrate CLT BEER WEEK

FAQ

  • What is pimento cheese?

    A traditional Southern spread that originated in the Northern states in the early 1900s. Made with a mixture of cheddar cheeses, mayonnaise, cream cheese, and spices. It can be enjoyed as a dip, on a grilled sandwich, or as a burger topping.

  • Do you offer bulk?

    Yes! You can order 1/2-gallon or 1-gallon tubs for use in restaurants, food trucks, or weddings.

  • How do you make vegan pimento cheese?

    The ingredients we use are vegan, diary-free, gluten-free, and plant-based by ‘Follow Your Heart’.

  • What is the shelf life?

    We do not use preservatives or freshness additives. The average shelf life is 60 days.

  • Can I get it shipped?

    At this time we are not set up to ship. Local pick-up in the greater Charlotte area.