Finicky Foods is more than pimento cheese.

Our little Bake Shoppe creates classic Southern desserts, French pastries and a few of our own longtime personal favorites.

email for custom orders

Whole Cakes, Pies, & More

Shortbread Scone - 8 pack Shortbread Scone - 8 pack Shortbread Scone - 8 pack Shortbread Scone - 8 pack Shortbread Scone - 8 pack Shortbread Scone - 8 pack Shortbread Scone - 8 pack Shortbread Scone - 8 pack Shortbread Scone - 8 pack Shortbread Scone - 8 pack Shortbread Scone - 8 pack Shortbread Scone - 8 pack Shortbread Scone - 8 pack Shortbread Scone - 8 pack
Sold out
Shortbread Scone - 8 pack
$32.00

butter crumb shortbread

French Macarons French Macarons
Sold out
French Macarons
$48.00

pillowy italian cookie sandwiches
3 of each:
chocolate peppermint
pistachio cream
winter cranberry
snickerdoodle

Cake
Cake
$60.00

Stuffed Brownie Bars - 15 pack Stuffed Brownie Bars - 15 pack Stuffed Brownie Bars - 15 pack Stuffed Brownie Bars - 15 pack Stuffed Brownie Bars - 15 pack
Sold out
Stuffed Brownie Bars - 15 pack
$36.00

fudgy brownie bars

Butter Crust Pie Butter Crust Pie Butter Crust Pie Butter Crust Pie Butter Crust Pie
Butter Crust Pie
$45.00

flaky butter crust
filling options: caramelized honey pumpkin, peach, strawberry rhubarb, cherry

IMG_1408.JPG
IMG_9223.JPG
IMG_1315.JPG
IMG_2068.JPG
IMG_2038.jpg
IMG_8914.jpg
IMG_9980.jpg
IMG_1300.JPG
IMG_0847.JPG
IMG_9343.JPG
IMG_9451.JPG
IMG_0170.JPG
IMG_0191.JPG
IMG_1520.JPG
IMG_9996.jpg
IMG_2635.jpg
IMG_0715.jpg
IMG_0188.JPG
IMG_1717.jpg
IMG_0068.JPG
email for custom orders